I read an article today citing a recent Pew Internet Research study that notes that (surprise!) some people are getting bored with Facebook. Articles predicting the demise of Facebook started cropping up not long after the mass market began to get familiar with the site. One reason seems to be that young early adopters don't like the fact that all these mass market/laggard/Luddites started stinking up the place, and sucking the cool out of the site. I know a young twentysomething who was an early adopter who dropped Facebook years ago -- only to find that she had to reluctantly re-engage with the site as part of her job working on the social media team for a cell phone company! Why is her company there? Because customers are there, and they reach out for customer service support, to give feedback, and to complain.

So, what's a marketer to do? Drop Faceboook? Reduce the emphasis on it? Stay the course? 

Depends on your customer base. Monolithic thinking never helps with marketing; what works for one company might totally bomb for another. Sure, people get bored with "the same old thing" over and over... and honestly I would not use Facebook at all if I didn't have to because it's pretty much expected, given what I do for a living. My reason is simply because as we all know "there's no such thing as a free lunch." 

Facebook is free to use -- because WE, the users, ARE the product. That's how they make their money -- highly targeted advertising and promoted posts. Facebook is a mechanical sifter of your individual interests that ensures access to you can be bought. We do this at my company every week as we place Facebook ads and promote posts: we're buying your attention. 

Sure, some people are going to drift away to something else... but then again, some people are passionate and totally "into" their Facebook lives. 

Thank heaven, we all have choices, and don't have to do the same thing!

 
 
Picture
A real BITCH: Brave, Intelligent, Tenacious, Creative & Honest
 TABATHA Coffey’s Tabatha Takes Over premiers tomorrow on Bravo.  This woman is in my pantheon of modern-day gods and goddesses; she is the Mars aspect of business in a female-dominated industry, and she is one tough boss.  Tabatha goes into underperforming hair salons and whips them into shape, a reality TV model perfected by Gordon Ramsay with Kitchen Nightmares and other shows. She’s steelier in the salon than Gordon Ramsay in the kitchen!

Hair salons and spas have a lot in common.  Although I haven't worked directly with hair salons, I was fortunate to partner with the esteemed spa industry expert, Nancy Griffin, for a few years before she sold industry insider site SpaTrade.com to American Spa Magazine. Nancy has a lot of the same toughness and practicality that Coffey exhibits; one thing I adored about working with Nancy was that she was ruthlessly matter-of-fact about the foibles and follies of spa owners -- who, like hair salon owners, tend to still be more mom-and-pop operations than major chains.    

The biggest point Nancy Griffin made to me, along with her colleague and friend, Peggy Wynne Borgman (president of Wynne Business Sps Consulting, whose company provides the best Spa Director management training courses available anywhere) is that when you ask spa owners what sets their business apart from the competition, the answer is most commonly "our customer service is the best".  No, it's not.  You cannot use customer service as your key differentiator if (a) every competitor also claims it as what makes them better, and (b) if it's a baseline expectation of your customers!  Can you imagine Sprint's CEO saying "what sets Sprint apart from other carriers is that we really do connect your phone calls" -- ???

That's why I love watching Tabitha, and Ramsay as well:  they don't let small business owners give them any BS about "what makes them special" -- and they call the owners on very fundamental issues of mismanagement, like demanding basic hygiene.

Tabatha has a new book out, and I grabbed a few excerpts from her Web site -- how can you not admire this sort of honesty?  Talk about knowing who you are and being comfortable in your skin!

Excerpted from  http://tabathacoffey.com/book:

 I always made it a point to say what I needed to say in order to accomplish what I needed to accomplish. Anyone who has worked with me knows that I don’t suffer fools easily and that I won’t hesitate to speak my mind. The irony of people’s reaction to my candor is that I just say what most people want to say but don’t have the balls to say. I tell the truth.

If, along the way, I’ve been called a bitch for being honest, I haven’t taken this personally. I developed a thick skin very early in life.

So I reclaimed the word “BITCH” as someone who is Brave, Intelligent, Tenacious, Creative, and Honest. And because I am all of these things, I now proudly own the title…

Bravery—Mine is derived from being a risk taker, personally and professionally, and from always being willing to face my demons head-on.

Intelligence—I’m no idiot. Despite having left school early to pursue my career, I’m well read, well traveled, street savvy, and I’m a successful businesswoman with a strong gut instinct. What’s more, unlike many women who don’t want to appear intimidating, I never downplay my intelligence. I believe women can be both smart and beautiful.

Tenacity—If I’m really passionate about something, I never give up. I’m like a pit bull with a bone. I have always battled for what I want and what I believe in, and if I have to dig deeper for the energy to keep going, then that’s what I do to achieve my goals.

Creativity—If I didn’t have this quality, I certainly wouldn’t be writing this book! I thoroughly enjoy expressing my creativ- ity in all aspects of life, whether I’m experimenting with a new haircut, sporting a new couture outfit, or adapting to a new challenge. Creativity keeps me engaged and makes my life that much more interesting while I am coping with whatever comes my way.

Honesty—I think I’ve already covered that, haven’t I? It is the key trait that makes people perceive a woman as a bitch—it intimidates people and rubs them the wrong way. Although this reaction is often due to sexism, women are more than capable of being intimidated, too. For me, honesty is saying what I think to the people around me, but it’s also about being honest with myself. If I can’t do that, then I can’t be honest with anyone.

The more I thought about my own positive spin on the term “bitch,” the more I realized that, on some level, everyone would like to be a little braver, or exercise a little more intelligence, or be a little more creative, or tenacious or honest. The truth is, all of us, women and men, have an inner bitch. We just have to choose how much of it to let out and when.


 
 
Picture
I read an interesting article from INC. today called "Are Your Employees Destroying your Business?".  It discusses the ways that the people we're around the most -- those we spend the most time with -- have a direct impact on our own psychology.  So, if your staff or coworkers are unpleasant and difficult to get along with, guess what?  YOU will begin to be the same way!  Even if you started out as an upbeat, positive person -- being surrounded by Eeyores will bring you down.  

Great point for businesses, and especially for smaller teams.  Nowadays, unless you're working for a major corporation, you're probably at a company where the teams consist of small groups.  Even at bigger companies, the typical day-to-day working group won't be huge... if "five people" are the magic attitude trigger, we need to pay close attention to the five people we spend the most time with.  And reality is that for most executives, we tend to spend more time with our work colleagues than we do with our own family; so the people we hire and work with are essential to our own mental health. Interesting to ponder, isn't it?  

 
 
  I just noticed this post on Alltop about how social media has plateaued.  I'm not surprised!  I remember when marketers got all hot and sweaty about email marketing in the mid-90's; it was supposed to kill off virtually all other types of media, and we;d even stop killing trees.  Anybody remember the promises of "the paperless office"???  

Twitter's tapering off... Chris Brogan made a great point about this, and as usual I agree with him. Believing you NEED more Twitter followers is like believing you NEED more Facebook friends.  Heck, I routinely bump people off my back because I don't cotton to spam or irrelevance.  

It's not going to die, certainly, but I think we'll start seeing a rebound in 2012, where people start to reconnect to other people in real life, face to face.  It will be interesting to see how the trends continue to shift.
 
 
Is it overly annoying to crow about such a little thing? Don't care.  Today was the first time I ranked as "Top Influencer" in the Microsoft Alumni and FTE LinkedIn group -- I've been experimenting a lot more this week with different types of social media tools, and ramping up how I use LinkedIn, and it's brought up some weird thoughts.One thing is that there are SO MANY social media apps, tools, platforms, etc. out there today, the past week has been sort of analogous to this scenario:  if I wanted a new CAR, I'd have to test drive virtually every type of car sold in the USA before I could make a decision.  Who has time for that?  I'd rather ignore 90% of what's available, and just go get a damn car that fits my needs well enough -- and if I happen to miss out on the perfect car because I didn't test drive every single model, no big whup.  I've got the wheels I need.  I think that's one of the reasons that for most types of product categories, there are one or two 800ob gorillas, and a slew of also-rans:  human brains love to categorize, and we definitely get sick of test-driving!  But I still think the Top Influencer thing on LinkedIn is cool, and I saved a screenshot of it.  Vanity, thy name is Laura, today!
 
 
Picture
I've been a fan of Alton Brown for several years.  His Web site bills him as "Just a Lowly Cook" -- but in reality, he's one of the top stars on the Food Network, having started by providing the English-overdubbed color commentary as Fuku-san on the original Japanese version of Iron Chef. Now, his Good Eats show is one of the freshest, most entertaining foodie shows ever made; truly disruptive and cool.

He posted this "Fanifesto" that outlines what he wants and expects regarding fan/celebrity interaction.  It's so interesting I'm reposting it in its entirety below, but the original is on his site at http://altonbrown.com/2011/09/my-fanifesto/.  

Why is this noteworthy?  Because, as he points out, there's become such a blurring of the lines between Fan and Celebrity in recent years, that it makes it challenging to be the guy at the center of attention.  Social media and cable TV have made a profound impact on the PERCEPTION of closeness some people think exists between them and a star.  

For example, nowadays you can pretty easily "find" just about anyone with a public profile -- either following them on Twitter or Facebook, their blog, fan sites, Wikipedia, etc  Didn't used to be that way.  

Here's his post:

My Fanifesto, by Alton Brown
Greetings,

Once upon a time fans knew what to expect from the fan/celebrity relationship. You could join a fan club, occasionally wait behind a barricade outside some theater or arena and hope for a live glimpse alongside a few thousand like-minded friends, buy periodicals featuring said celebrity, or actively stalk thus risking the wrath of security personnel, both public and private.

Today there are still megastars who fit the old model…George Clooney comes to mind, but the rest of us fit into an ever widening, Warholian spiral of quasi-celebrity. We are the cable-ebrities and the web-ebrities, and unlike the Liz and Dicks of the world, we live, work, eat, shop, worship, and recreate right alongside the rest of you. We don’t have gated mansions, entourages, or bodyguards. We wait in lines, drop off the dry cleaning, and interact regularly with the “citizens” around us (that’s celebrity-speak for non-famous folk). This situation often stretches the very fabric of our society because we just don’t have rules for this sort of thing.

Since I’m about to go out on book tour and meet several thousand of you for the first or second or third time I thought I’d give you my rules for this sort of thing…just so we’re all on the same page.

First, please know that I sincerely appreciate you. If you are a fan, I am beyond thrilled that you like my work. Rest assured, should the opportune arise, I will go out of my way to enhance your fan experience. I will autograph just about anything (read on), I will pose for pictures (as long as they’re respectfully tasteful), and will honestly talk with you without looking over your shoulder at the next person coming down the line, no matter how limited the time. And, I will bust my butt to make sure the television program you’re watching or book you’re reading is the best I can do and fairly priced. Now…

• If you encounter me out in the world and want an autograph or to take a picture with me I will say “yes” if I can possibly manage the time. If I am with my family I will probably still say “yes”, but I will want to move away from my family to do so. If you purposely take a picture a picture of my family I will go freakin’ ballistic. I’m quasi-famous, they’re not. They enjoy certain rights I have sacrificed by choosing to be a cable-ebrity and as a husband and father I will protect their rights to the fullest.

• Please don’t ask me to talk to someone on the phone. This is crossing the line. I’ll sign an autograph for your mom but I’m not going to get on the phone to sing her “Happy Birthday”. Same for video. Please don’t ask me to star in a shout-out to that friend who couldn’t be there. It makes both of us look creepy.

• Please understand that social media is very difficult to manage. Cable-ebrities can choose to interact with no one at all or a random few, but we can’t interact with everyone or we wouldn’t get any work done. If you are the kind of person who takes offense at being “snubbed” on social media, please don’t follow or friend me as disappointment is all but guaranteed.

• When I’m on book tour, I try to keep physical contact to a minimum. This is for your protection as well as my own. I usually tour during the start of cold/flu season and I don’t want to be responsible for accelerating the spread of what could be a potentially deadly illness. Please respect this effort by not asking me for a hug.

• Yes I’ll sign things besides books. Spoons, cutting boards, mixers, you name it I’ll sign it. But I won’t sign living things. Not you, not your hamster, not your ferret. I’ll sign your cast but not your arm. This is because hamsters often bite and most permanent markers are somewhat toxic.

• Please don’t block my exit. One time on a commercial flight a guy blocked the aisle and didn’t want to let anyone deplane until I signed something for him. My lizard-like brain interpreted this behavior as a threat. Luckily an air marshal was on the flight and stepped in just as I was considering a range of actions, any of which would probably have resulted in my being barred from future commercial flights.

• Please don’t talk to me in a public restroom. Odds are good I’m there for a specific reason and I need to concentrate on what I’m doing. Wait for me outside and I’ll be ever so grateful.

• 99% of fans are completely cool. They understand how to act in public and they respect my space and time as I do theirs. This is a testament to good old fashion manners and a societal code based on common rights. However, fans ocassionaly mutate into Fanatics who develop a sense of entitlement, a sense that their heightened level of fandom puts me in debt to them. I don’t see it that way. If you bake me a pie, draw me a picture or design a website about me, that’s great. I appreciate it very much. But I don’t owe you a darned thing unless you want $12 for the pie, which is probably fair. Be forewarned though: I usually don’t have any money on me.

• When tackling large signings I try to move fast to get you home. I will often ask that families with small children be allowed to come to the front of the line so that they can get out and to bed at a decent hour. This means some of you will have to wait a little longer. Thank you in advance for your patience. What I promise in return for this consideration is to never sit at a signing (so my feet will hurt just as bad as yours) and to never leave until the last fan has been greeted and their goods duly signed. I never have and never will (unless I have a stroke or something) left fans in the lurch.

• Concerning photos: I love making memories as much as the next guy but we’re having to put the kibosh on phone pictures because they’re slow, ponderous and most people (not you of course) don’t know how to use them. As a result we end up standing there long enough for an etching, which can get a little awkward. If you want a picture, bring a camera and have it ready. I will have someone with me who is well versed in its use and we’ll look great when he’s done. Again: camera=good, phone=bad.

• When it’s over, it’s over. I’ll stay to the last but then we simply must be going. In most cases we’re flying to the next city right away rather than retiring to the comfort of a local pub or a fancy hotel. We’ve got hours to go before heads hit beds and appreciate your understanding.

Well, that about wraps it up. We’re looking forward to a great tour and great crowds. I’m proud as heck of this new book and hope you’ll find it a useful addition to your library, kitchen, bedroom, bathroom, garage. If any of the above seems vague or confusing, print it out and we’ll review when we meet.

Alton




 
 
Picture
I just got home from a lovely visit to Orlando, where I was a featured presenter at the Marketing Innovation Summit presented by Unica.  I love public speaking and I'm a total ham, plus I was really jazzed about the topic I presented on:  marketing operations.  Now, that sounds boring, but in reality, if you run a marketing organization, you simply have to have some sort of project management tool.  This is the one I selected for our company before 37signal's Campfire really started to talk hold.  Unica's Marketing Operations OnDemand (MOOD) tool works great.  
However, the coolest part of this conference was the simple fact that I got to spend time with other marketing execs from a whole slew of brands that I admire:  BestBuy, Guitar Center, Boots (UK), Disney... plus a really smart Forrester analyst who talked about the need for a new sort of position:  an integrated marketing exec role that has deep understanding of both new and emerging channels.  That's where I intend to head for my career.  I've loved online marketing since I started at my first Internet company in 1995, and I learn something new every week.  The fascinating part is figuring out how to understand which type of tactic or approach is best for a given situation: marketing strategy becomes more and more complicated every year -- while paradoxically, it's also simplified because no matter what, you have to find the channels that resonate best with your target audience and maximize the use of them.  There are so many different channels today, that's not always an easy trick to pull!